Interview with Phylis Warady
October 27th, 2006How long have you been writing?
45 years, seriously. I took journalism in HS and always dabbled. I sometimes begin a bio: “I began writing with three children under five to save my sanity.”
People smile. Nowadays, I smile too. But not at the time. You see, a year after my son was born, I still suffered from postpartum depression. Deemed physically healthy, I was referred to a psychologist of the school that promised quick results. He was a great guy, really! He and my GP keep urging me to write.
At first, I resisted. I could envision the guys arriving in white coats and dragging me off in a straitjacket. Even if they never showed up I was miserable. So I decided to give it a go. That first year I wrote my way free of my suppressed anger; and ever since have been convinced that basically depression is anger turned inward.
Back to the beginning of this saga: Within a week of my decision to write, I had a weekly column in the town weekly. But after a year or so of writing straight news, features and my column, I realized I wanted to write fiction.
So I talked hubby into sending my two and three year old kids off to nursery school twice a week and enrolled in WD’s correspondence course for fiction. They went for a half day, were fed a hot lunch and arrived back home in time for their naps. (The eldest child, now 6 was in 1st grade.)
Even so, it took me 2 years to complete the course. Transition from writing fiction as opposed to non-fiction wasn’t easy. When I free-lanced for the newspaper, every thing I wrote was accepted. My perk was unlimited newsprint to type upon.
Whereas my fiction efforts met with constant rejection. But I persisted, and my short stories began to be accepted and published. So I moved on to novels, where I wasn’t immediately embraced either. I’d written 9 books before my first novel was accepted by Walker and Company. (4 of the 9 were subsequently published)
How many books have you had published?
Short answer: 5 books, 1 novella. All are Traditional Regencies. Their respective track records may be of interest. All were published out of order as to when initially written.
SCANDAL’S DAUGHTER: published in 1990 by Walker and Company Mary Elizabeth Allen, was my editor, I still miss her keen eye and advice.
THE EARL’S COMEUPPANCE: published in 1991 by Walker and Company. The Earl’s Comeuppance was originally dubbed ‘Henrietta’ and went to contract with Harlequin in 1981. Terms of their contract specified that they publish it within 22 months. Their Hollywood office closed. My editor didn’t want to move to Toronto, so married for the 3rd time instead. Meaning my book was orphaned. Hell’s fire, the entire line was orphaned.
When Harlequin finally began to actually publish the line, my contract had expired–meaning they’d have had to pay me another advance. They elected to pass–a heartbreaker personally–but wise from a business standpoint. Especially as traditional regencies had burgeoned in 1980 and by 1982 had pretty much tanked, unless the author was firmly established.
In 1997, Comeuppance was a finalist for the Golden Heart (a completely rewritten version). And was finally published by Walker and Company in 1991, a decade after it sold to Harlequin. In 2005 Thorndike Press brought out a large print addition and in 2007, it will be reissued by Cerridwen/Cotillion. Ditto Scandal’s Daughter.
THE GOLDEN SWAN: published in 1994 by Kensington. Initially SWAN was contracted to Walker and Company. But the owner died and his son didn’t care for regencies. So they returned all rights to me and I got to keep the advance. (As I did with Harlequin when they elected not to publish COMEUPPANCE.) I then sold these rights to Kensington. And once reverted, sold them to Cerridwen/Cotillion. It’s scheduled to be released in 2007.
THE PERSISTENT SUITOR: Published in 1995 by Kensington. (This was actually, the first regency I wrote in the mid-80’s, completely rewritten a decade later of course.
BREACH OF HONOR: Published in 1995 by Kensington.
DELIGHTFUL DECEIVER: (Novella published by Kensington, appears in Flowers for the Bride Anthology, 1995, reissued in German in 1999).
What genre and/or sub-genre do you write in?
All my novels–novellas are traditional regencies. However, all my short fiction is contemporary. Why? No idea. Though I do love researching for my historicals.
When was your first book published? What was it about?
First Book Published: Scandal’s Daughter in 1990. Backstory: The Earl of Sandwich had a mistress named Martha Raye, whom he lived with openly. He introduced her as his protégé with a gorgeous soprano voice. Didn’t sing in public, but did privately at musicals in their home. They had 3 kids, all reputed to have turned out well despite the scandal
that ensued when Martha’s lover shoots her in front of the opera house. She dies; lover is hanged; Earl grieves. The heroine is my take on what happened to their daughter; purely fiction, of course.
Do you have an agent? If so, did your agent sell your first book to a publisher, or did you do that on your own?
Not at present. Actually I’ve never had any trouble getting an agent. I’ve had 7, 5 before being published. I’ve even had what is termed a ‘top’ agent. What I’ve learned is that any agent, even one considered at the top of the heap, is worst than none unless said agent simply adores every word you write. Well maybe not every word, but most of them. So I look but, so far, haven’t found a good match.
How did you contact your agent/publisher? Did you query them, pitch to them at a conference or final in a contest?
Scorecard: I meet all agents and/or editors at various functions. However, I’d already been offered a contract when I settled on an agent (the so-called ‘top’ one). Thus, I never learned what either he or his female assistant thought of my work. I got on well with both, but hope never to become dead-ended again. I actually did sell my first book myself and all the others as well.
As for the publishers: For Walker I met Alice Orr at a conference, and after many months, the new editor called me with an offer.
At Kensington: Jennifer Sawyer (Fischer) was a brand new editor at Kensington when she visited our Chapter. I was the prez. She sat beside me. I told her my sad tale: Long-time writing buddy, Jeanne Savery, had recently become contracted to Kensington. She’d written for Walker but, like me, and 20+ authors became homeless with Walker’s decision to no longer publish traditional regencies. I told Jennifer how hard it was for me to congratulate Jeanne and mean it. (Kensington has now cancelled their line, but one of Jeanne’s books was a 2005 Rita Finalist. Didn’t win though. Had she won, it would’ve been a nice consolation prize.) To pick up the thread of this tale, Jennifer flew back to NYC, located my manuscript and bought it–as well as two more and a novella.
And this year, of course, Raelene Gorlinsky, visited us in January. As a result I’m now contracted for 3 books with Cerridwen/Cotillion.
What were you doing when you got “The Call”?
The most amusing account I suppose, is the first time this happened. Initially, I submitted Comeuppance to Harlequin. Grippo liked the book but was over-budget. Might be willing to purchase later. So I said in that case I planned to submit elsewhere. Her reply? “I can’t in good conscience forbid it.”
I then submitted it to Ellen Edwards at Dell. She returned the ms. It arrived on my doorstep (literally because it wouldn’t fit through the letter slot in the door) on my birthday. Very annoyed. I knew is a good book. Her letter stated she loved it, but wanted me to add 50 pages. No problem–since a reread revealed I’d left out the ‘black moment’. (More careful now–I swear it!) Added 50 pages; shipped it off to Dell.
Four months later, on April 2, 1981, I got the ‘call’ from Grippo. “Would’ve called you yesterday, but thought you might think it a joke.” Offers me a decent advance and royalties. I’m on cloud nine.
On April 3, Edwards calls. She wants Comeuppance too; offers a larger advance, higher royalties. I told her about the Harlequin offer. Tells me to call her back in a week with my final decision. Won’t send contract until she hears from me.
I think about it a bit then call Grippo and tell her about Dell’s offer. But I’m not smart enough to shut my mouth and let her speak. I accept her offer for two reasons. 1. Their Hollywood office, were I can meet my editor in person; 2. Harlequin publishes worldwide. I figure I’ll make more money with them than I would with Dell.
The painful truth: If there were ever a time when I could’ve used a savvy agent it was at this crucial point. Said agent would have raised the ante. Had I done that, Harlequin might well have decided they had too much invested already not to publish me in 1981, meaning I wouldn’t have been sidelined when regencies tanked shortly thereafter.
So if I’ve been a bit harsh on agents in general, let me add that a good, competent agent with your best interests at heart at crucial points in your career can be worth their weight in gold.
Have you won any awards?
I have no major awards. However The Earl’s Comeuppance was a 1987 Golden Heart Finalist; Scandal’s Daughter a 1989 Maggie Finalist: The Persistent Suitor a 1996 Virginia Holt Medallion Finalist.
Tell us about your latest book. What’s the title and when will it be released?
I’m hard at work on Virtue and Vice which I hope shall be my 6th published regency and which Cerridwen/Cotillion has expressed an interest. V&V finaled in both The Royal Ascot & 2006 Great Beginnings.
Anything else: I also write award-winning short fiction and non-fiction articles published widely in the USA and Canada.

